The Resource Controversy and Consensus: Nuclear Beta Decay 1911-1934

Controversy and Consensus: Nuclear Beta Decay 1911-1934

Controversy and Consensus: Nuclear Beta Decay 1911-1934
Controversy and Consensus: Nuclear Beta Decay 1911-1934
Title variation
  • Science Networks · Historical Studies, vol. 24
  • Controversy and Consensus
  • eng
  • eng
To all four of us, Carsten was the best possible friend and colleague. To Finn, he was a fellow student in the history of science for several years at the Niels Bohr Institute; to Relge, he was a welcome resource for personal and intellectual interac­ tion in an otherwise less than fertile environment for the history of science; Roger was Carsten's friend and advisor, not least in the development of the dissertation on which the present book is based; and as director of the Niels Bohr Archive, Erik was his main advisor in his historical work. Because he was the person closest to Carsten's work on his Ph. D. dissertation on the history of beta decay, on which the present book is based, it is only fitting that Erik stands as single author of the words in Carsten's memory at the very beginning of this book. Before his untimely death shortly after the completion of the Ph. D. disser­ tation, Carsten had himself plans to develop the dissertation into a book. Being a true perfectionist, he wanted to rework the manuscript substantively, especially with regard to relating it to the broader discussion among historians of science
Member of
Is part of
Cataloging source
Dewey number
Image bit depth
Language note
LC call number
Series statement
Science Networks · Historical Studies
Series volume
Controversy and Consensus: Nuclear Beta Decay 1911-1934
Bibliographic Level Mode of Issuance: Monograph
Antecedent source
Carrier category
online resource
Carrier category code
not applicable
Content category
Content type code
1 Prelude: Beta-Spectrum Research in the Pre-Nuclear Years, 1900–1911 -- 1.1 Discovery and identification of the beta particle -- 1.2 The first experiments on the velocity distribution of beta particles -- 1.3 Absorption measurements question the inhomogeneity of the beta particles -- 1.4 The Hahn-Meitner vs. Wilson controversy -- 1.5 From unity to complexity: magnetic-deflection experiments, 1910–1911 -- 2 The Origin of Beta Rays, and the Growing Complexity of Their Spectrum: The Rutherford Era, 1911–1919 -- 2.1 Introduction -- 2.2 Rutherford’s 1912 theory, and reactions to it -- 2.3 The beta particle as a nuclear constituent -- 2.4 An extreme complexity of beta line-spectra is brought to light: deflection experiments in the years 1911–1913 -- 2.5 Continuity as well as lines: The composite beta spectrum -- 2.6 Rutherford’s 1914 theory -- 2.7 The Bohr-Sommerfeld quantum conditions and the beta line-spectrum -- 2.8 Rutherford and the gamma rays -- 3 The Rise of a Controversy: Ellis, Meitner and Smekal Advance Different Beta-Spectrum Theories, 1920–1922 -- 3.1 Introduction -- 3.2 Internal conversion, nuclear levels, and Ellis’s interpretation of the beta line-spectrum -- 3.3 Analogy between alpha and beta emission, and Meitner’s interpretation of the beta line-spectrum -- 3.4 Ellis’s response to Meitner’s hypothesis, and his interpretation of the continuous beta spectrum -- 3.5 Meitner replies to Ellis, and reveals her view on the continuous beta spectrum -- 3.6 The atom as a unity: Smekal joins the discussion, and is met with a sharp reaction -- 3.7 Two repetitions of the Chadwick experiment lead to contradictory conclusions -- 4 Secondary Effects and Order of Emission: Two Main Questions in the Controversy, 1923–1925 -- 4.1 Introduction -- 4.2 Meitner investigates the beta spectrum of UX1 and takes it as further support for her view -- 4.3 Radiationless transitions: Rosseland suggests an explanation of the emission of primary, and some secondary, beta particles -- 4.4 The nuclear field and the Compton effect: Two possible reasons for the continuous beta spectrum -- 4.5 Ellis and Skinner reinvestigate the beta line-spectra of RaB and C, and serious problems arise -- 4.6 Beta first, gamma second, or is it the other way around? -- 5 The End of the Beginning: The Controversy Enters the Decisive Phase, 1925–1929 -- 5.1 Introduction -- 5.2 Ellis adjusts his view on the emission process, but maintains his interpretation of the continuous spectrum -- 5.3 The number of emitted beta particles -- 5.4 Ellis and Wooster’s tour de force: A determination of the heating effect of RaE -- 5.5 Continental reactions to Ellis and Wooster’s experiment -- 5.6 Some concluding remarks about the controversy -- 6 From Anomaly to Explanation: The Continuous Beta Spectrum, 1929–1934 -- 6.1 Introduction -- 6.2 Non-conservation of energy or a new particle? The first phase of the Bohr-Pauli dispute, 1929–1932 -- 6.3 Other attempts at explaining the anomalous continuity -- 6.4 The question of upper limits in beta spectra, and the thorium C branching problem -- 6.5 The impact of the miraculous year: The second phase of the Bohr-Pauli dispute, 1932–1933 -- 6.6 The two theories of beta decay -- 7 Towards a Theory of Internal Conversion: The Beta Line-Spectrum, 1927–1934 -- 7.1 Introduction -- 7.2 Experimental evidence brings about a new view on the origin of gamma rays -- 7.3 The radiation hypothesis proves insufficient to explain internal conversion of gamma rays -- 7.4 A theory of internal conversion is developed -- Summary and Conclusion -- Name Index
1 online resource (XVII, 217 p.)
File format
multiple file formats
Form of item
Level of compression
Media category
Media type code
Other control number
Quality assurance targets
Reformatting quality
Specific material designation
System control number
  • (CKB)3400000000101588
  • (SSID)ssj0001275166
  • (PQKBManifestationID)11726612
  • (PQKBTitleCode)TC0001275166
  • (PQKBWorkID)11352536
  • (PQKB)10894525
  • (DE-He213)978-3-0348-8444-0
  • (EXLCZ)993400000000101588

Library Locations

  • Albert D. Cohen Management LibraryBorrow it
    181 Freedman Crescent, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 5V4, CA
    49.807878 -97.129961
  • Architecture/Fine Arts LibraryBorrow it
    84 Curry Place, Winnipeg, MB, CA
    49.807716 -97.136226
  • Archives and Special CollectionsBorrow it
    25 Chancellors Circle (Elizabeth Dafoe Library), Room 330, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, CA
    49.809961 -97.131878
  • Bibliothèque Alfred-Monnin (Université de Saint-Boniface)Borrow it
    200, avenue de la Cathédrale, Local 2110, Winnipeg, MB, R2H 0H7, CA
    49.888861 -97.119735
  • Bill Larson Library (Grace Hospital)Borrow it
    300 Booth Drive, G-227, Winnipeg, MB, R3J 3M7, CA
    49.882400 -97.276436
  • Carolyn Sifton - Helene Fuld Library (St. Boniface General Hospital)Borrow it
    409 Tache Avenue, Winnipeg, MB, R2H 2A6, CA
    49.883388 -97.126050
  • Concordia Hospital LibraryBorrow it
    1095 Concordia Avenue, Winnipeg, MB, R2K 3S8, CA
    49.913252 -97.064683
  • Donald W. Craik Engineering LibraryBorrow it
    75B Chancellors Circle (Engineering Building E3), Room 361, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, CA
    49.809053 -97.133292
  • E.K. Williams Law LibraryBorrow it
    224 Dysart Road, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 5V4, CA
    49.811829 -97.131017
  • Eckhardt-Gramatté Music LibraryBorrow it
    136 Dafoe Road (Taché Arts Complex), Room 257, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, CA
    49.807964 -97.132222
  • Elizabeth Dafoe LibraryBorrow it
    25 Chancellors Circle, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, CA
    49.809961 -97.131878
  • Fr. H. Drake Library (St. Paul's College)Borrow it
    70 Dysart Road, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2M6, CA
    49.810605 -97.138184
  • J.W. Crane Memorial Library (Deer Lodge Centre)Borrow it
    2109 Portage Avenue, Winnipeg, MB, R3J 0L3, CA
    49.878000 -97.235520
  • Libraries Annex (not open to the public; please see web page for details)Borrow it
    25 Chancellors Circle (in the Elizabeth Dafoe Library), Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2, CA
    49.809961 -97.131878
  • Neil John Maclean Health Sciences LibraryBorrow it
    727 McDermot Avenue (Brodie Centre), 200 Level, Winnipeg, MB, R3E 3P5, CA
    49.903563 -97.160554
  • Sciences and Technology LibraryBorrow it
    186 Dysart Road, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2M8, CA
    49.811526 -97.133257
  • Seven Oaks General Hospital LibraryBorrow it
    2300 McPhillips Street, Winnipeg, MB, R2V 3M3, CA
    49.955177 -97.148865
  • Sister St. Odilon Library (Misericordia Health Centre)Borrow it
    99 Cornish Avenue, Winnipeg, MB, R3C 1A2, CA
    49.879592 -97.160425
  • St. John's College LibraryBorrow it
    92 Dysart Road, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2M5, CA
    49.811242 -97.137156
  • Victoria General Hospital LibraryBorrow it
    2340 Pembina Highway, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2E8, CA
    49.806755 -97.152739
  • William R Newman Library (Agriculture)Borrow it
    66 Dafoe Road, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2R3, CA
    49.806936 -97.135525
Processing Feedback ...